Labor votes against helping farmers
21 FEBRUARY 2019: Labor voted against the Future Drought Bill in parliament today. Fortunately, they did not have the numbers to stop it passing, but it does demonstrate their lack of concern for anyone outside the capital cities.
For the record, I have copied and pasted below the official record of the vote as recorded by Hansard. The first votes are whether or not to bring debate to a close and and ask the parliament to vote on the bill. The second votes are the actual vote on the bill.
16 FUTURE DROUGHT FUND BILL 2018
The order of the day having been read for the resumption of the debate on the question—That the bill be now read a second time—
Debate resumed.
- 12:16:57 PM
Cognate debate with Future Drought Fund (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2018.
Ms Sharkie, 12:17:16 PM.- 12:27:00 PM
Document
Ms Sharkie, by leave, presented the following document:
Australian Academy of Science—Investigation of the causes of mass fish kills in the Menindee Region NSW over the summer of 2018-2019.
- 12:27:43 PM
Closure
Mr Pyne (Leader of the House) moved—That the question be now put.
Question—That the question be now put—put.
- 12:28:11 PM
Division 462
The House divided (the Speaker, Mr A. D. H. Smith, in the Chair)—
AYES, 75
Mr Abbott | Mr Fletcher | Mr Leeser | Mr Pyne |
Mrs K. L. Andrews | Ms Flint | Ms Ley | Mr Ramsey* |
Mr K. J. Andrews | Mr Gee | Mr Littleproud | Mr Robert |
Ms Banks | Dr Gillespie | Mr McCormack | Ms Sharkie |
Ms Bishop | Mr Goodenough | Ms McGowan | Mrs Sudmalis |
Mr Broad | Mr Hartsuyker | Dr McVeigh | Mr Taylor |
Mr Broadbent | Mr Hastie | Mrs Marino | Mr Tehan |
Mr Buchholz | Mr Hawke | Mr Morrison | Mr Tudge |
Mr D. J. Chester | Ms Henderson | Mr Morton | Mr van Manen |
Mr Christensen | Mr Hogan | Mr Ted O’Brien | Mr Vasta |
Mr Ciobo | Mr Howarth | Mr L. S. O’Brien | Mr Wallace |
Mr Coleman | Mr Hunt | Mr O’Dowd | Mrs Wicks |
Mr Coulton | Mr Irons | Ms O’Dwyer | Mr Wilkie |
Mr Crewther | Mr Joyce | Mr Pasin | Mr R. J. Wilson |
Mr Drum* | Mr Katter | Dr Phelps | Mr T. R. Wilson |
Mr Dutton | Mr Keenan | Mr Pitt | Mr Wood |
Mr Entsch | Mr C. Kelly | Mr Porter | Mr Wyatt |
Mr Evans | Mr Laming | Mrs Prentice | Mr Zimmerman |
Mr Falinski | Ms M. L. Landry | Ms Price |
NOES, 66
Mr Albanese | Mr Conroy | Ms Keay | Ms O’Toole |
Dr Aly | Mr Danby | Dr M. J. Kelly | Mr Perrett* |
Mr Bandt | Mr Dick | Mr Keogh | Ms Plibersek |
Ms Bird | Mr Dreyfus | Mr Khalil | Ms Rishworth |
Mr Bowen | Mrs Elliot | Ms C. F. King | Ms Rowland |
Ms Brodtmann | Ms Ellis | Ms M. M. H. King | Ms Ryan* |
Mr Burke | Mr Fitzgibbon | Ms Lamb | Mr Shorten |
Ms Burney | Dr Freelander | Dr Leigh | Ms Stanley |
Mr M. C. Butler | Mr Georganas | Ms McBride | Mr Swan |
Ms T. M. Butler | Mr Giles | Ms Macklin | Ms Swanson |
Mr Byrne | Mr Gorman | Mr Marles | Ms Templeman |
Dr Chalmers | Mr Gosling | Mr B. K. Mitchell | Mr Thistlethwaite |
Mr Champion | Mr Hayes | Mr R. G. Mitchell | Ms Vamvakinou |
Ms L. M. Chesters | Mr Hill | Mr Neumann | Mr Watts |
Mr Clare | Mr Husic | Mr O’Connor | Mr J. H. Wilson |
Ms Claydon | Mr Jones | Ms O’Neil | Mr Zappia |
Ms Collins | Ms Kearney |
* Tellers
And so it was resolved in the affirmative.
- 12:36:19 PM
And the question—That the bill be now read a second time—being accordingly put—
- 12:36:38 PM
Division 463
The House divided (the Speaker, Mr A. D. H. Smith, in the Chair)—
AYES, 75
Mr Abbott | Mr Fletcher | Mr Leeser | Mr Pyne |
Mrs K. L. Andrews | Ms Flint | Ms Ley | Mr Ramsey* |
Mr K. J. Andrews | Mr Gee | Mr Littleproud | Mr Robert |
Ms Banks | Dr Gillespie | Mr McCormack | Ms Sharkie |
Ms Bishop | Mr Goodenough | Ms McGowan | Mrs Sudmalis |
Mr Broad | Mr Hartsuyker | Dr McVeigh | Mr Taylor |
Mr Broadbent | Mr Hastie | Mrs Marino | Mr Tehan |
Mr Buchholz | Mr Hawke | Mr Morrison | Mr Tudge |
Mr D. J. Chester | Ms Henderson | Mr Morton | Mr van Manen |
Mr Christensen | Mr Hogan | Mr Ted O’Brien | Mr Vasta |
Mr Ciobo | Mr Howarth | Mr L. S. O’Brien | Mr Wallace |
Mr Coleman | Mr Hunt | Mr O’Dowd | Mrs Wicks |
Mr Coulton | Mr Irons | Ms O’Dwyer | Mr Wilkie |
Mr Crewther | Mr Joyce | Mr Pasin | Mr R. J. Wilson |
Mr Drum* | Mr Katter | Dr Phelps | Mr T. R. Wilson |
Mr Dutton | Mr Keenan | Mr Pitt | Mr Wood |
Mr Entsch | Mr C. Kelly | Mr Porter | Mr Wyatt |
Mr Evans | Mr Laming | Mrs Prentice | Mr Zimmerman |
Mr Falinski | Ms M. L. Landry | Ms Price |
NOES, 66
Mr Albanese | Mr Conroy | Ms Keay | Ms O’Toole |
Dr Aly | Mr Danby | Dr M. J. Kelly | Mr Perrett* |
Mr Bandt | Mr Dick | Mr Keogh | Ms Plibersek |
Ms Bird | Mr Dreyfus | Mr Khalil | Ms Rishworth |
Mr Bowen | Mrs Elliot | Ms C. F. King | Ms Rowland |
Ms Brodtmann | Ms Ellis | Ms M. M. H. King | Ms Ryan* |
Mr Burke | Mr Fitzgibbon | Ms Lamb | Mr Shorten |
Ms Burney | Dr Freelander | Dr Leigh | Ms Stanley |
Mr M. C. Butler | Mr Georganas | Ms McBride | Mr Swan |
Ms T. M. Butler | Mr Giles | Ms Macklin | Ms Swanson |
Mr Byrne | Mr Gorman | Mr Marles | Ms Templeman |
Dr Chalmers | Mr Gosling | Mr B. K. Mitchell | Mr Thistlethwaite |
Mr Champion | Mr Hayes | Mr R. G. Mitchell | Ms Vamvakinou |
Ms L. M. Chesters | Mr Hill | Mr Neumann | Mr Watts |
Mr Clare | Mr Husic | Mr O’Connor | Mr J. H. Wilson |
Ms Claydon | Mr Jones | Ms O’Neil | Mr Zappia |
Ms Collins | Ms Kearney |
* Tellers
And so it was resolved in the affirmative.
- 12:38:50 PM
—bill read a second time.
- 12:38:59 PM
Message from the Governor-General
Message No. 243, 26 November 2018, from His Excellency the Governor-General was announced recommending an appropriation for the purposes of the bill.
- 12:39:23 PM
Consideration in detail
Bill, by leave, taken as a whole.
- 12:39:26 PM
On the motion of Ms McGowan, by leave, amendments (1) to (10) were made together, after debate.
Mr Fitzgibbon, 12:43:55 PM. Mr Albanese, 12:47:43 PM. Mr Littleproud, 12:50:00 PM. Ms Sharkie, 12:51:24 PM.- 12:54:26 PM
Question—That the bill, as amended, be agreed to—put.
- 12:54:50 PM
Division 464
The House divided (the Speaker, Mr A. D. H. Smith, in the Chair)—
AYES, 74
Mr Abbott | Mr Fletcher | Ms Ley | Mr Ramsey* |
Mr Alexander | Ms Flint | Mr Littleproud | Mr Robert |
Mrs K. L. Andrews | Mr Gee | Mr McCormack | Ms Sharkie |
Mr K. J. Andrews | Dr Gillespie | Ms McGowan | Mrs Sudmalis |
Ms Banks | Mr Goodenough | Dr McVeigh | Mr Sukkar |
Ms Bishop | Mr Hartsuyker | Mrs Marino | Mr Taylor |
Mr Broad | Mr Hastie | Mr Morrison | Mr Tehan |
Mr Broadbent | Mr Hawke | Mr Morton | Mr Tudge |
Mr Buchholz | Ms Henderson | Mr Ted O’Brien | Mr van Manen |
Mr D. J. Chester | Mr Hogan | Mr L. S. O’Brien | Mr Vasta |
Mr Christensen | Mr Hunt | Mr O’Dowd | Mr Wallace |
Mr Ciobo | Mr Irons | Ms O’Dwyer | Mrs Wicks |
Mr Coleman | Mr Joyce | Mr Pasin | Mr Wilkie |
Mr Coulton | Mr Katter | Mr Pitt | Mr R. J. Wilson |
Mr Crewther | Mr Keenan | Mr Porter | Mr T. R. Wilson |
Mr Drum* | Mr C. Kelly | Mrs Prentice | Mr Wood |
Mr Dutton | Mr Laming | Ms Price | Mr Wyatt |
Mr Entsch | Ms M. L. Landry | Mr Pyne | Mr Zimmerman |
Mr Falinski | Mr Leeser |
NOES, 67
Mr Albanese | Mr Conroy | Ms Keay | Mr Perrett* |
Dr Aly | Mr Danby | Dr M. J. Kelly | Dr Phelps |
Mr Bandt | Mr Dick | Mr Keogh | Ms Plibersek |
Ms Bird | Mr Dreyfus | Mr Khalil | Ms Rishworth |
Mr Bowen | Mrs Elliot | Ms C. F. King | Ms Rowland |
Ms Brodtmann | Ms Ellis | Ms M. M. H. King | Ms Ryan* |
Mr Burke | Mr Fitzgibbon | Ms Lamb | Mr Shorten |
Ms Burney | Dr Freelander | Dr Leigh | Ms Stanley |
Mr M. C. Butler | Mr Georganas | Ms McBride | Mr Swan |
Ms T. M. Butler | Mr Giles | Ms Macklin | Ms Swanson |
Mr Byrne | Mr Gorman | Mr Marles | Ms Templeman |
Dr Chalmers | Mr Gosling | Mr B. K. Mitchell | Mr Thistlethwaite |
Mr Champion | Mr Hayes | Mr R. G. Mitchell | Ms Vamvakinou |
Ms L. M. Chesters | Mr Hill | Mr Neumann | Mr Watts |
Mr Clare | Mr Husic | Mr O’Connor | Mr J. H. Wilson |
Ms Claydon | Mr Jones | Ms O’Neil | Mr Zappia |
Ms Collins | Ms Kearney | Ms O’Toole |
* Tellers
And so it was resolved in the affirmative.
- 1:01:31 PM
Bill, as amended, agreed to.
Consideration in detail concluded.
- 1:01:50 PM
On the motion of Mr Taylor (Minister for Energy), by leave, the bill was read a third time.